pages

Monday, September 9, 2013

Self Deprecation and Having it All

I loved Seinfeld when I was a kid.  As I have slowly transitioned into a socially awkward Larry David-Jerry Seinfeld hybrid (really, I hate hugging people 'hello'), I've found myself becoming incredibly self-deprecating.  Is this cute, or the sign of someone with terribly low self-esteem?  People laugh at the jokes I make at my own expense and insist that they must not be true, but do they really see these things just as jokes or does this just bring their attention to the flaws in myself that I dwell on everyday?  Do I really see these comments as jokes or do I feel that way about myself?

This kind of self deprecation is closely related to the inability to take a compliment.  There is a scene in "Mean Girls" that is incredibly poignant (yes, I said that) where the main mean girl tells the new girl she is very pretty.  The new girl accepts the compliment and says "thanks!" which prompts the mean girl to reply, "So you agree, you think you're really pretty?"  It's so hard to take a compliment without sounding vain, and hard to deflect one without sounding insecure.  When we deflect compliments, is that our way of conveying that we think so low of ourselves that we find it hard to believe anyone could have something nice to say?

I hate standing out or being noticed.  I work as a chemical engineer and am the only female programmer in my company.  I try to dress plainly so as not to draw attention to myself, I follow up my ideas with "or something" so as not to seem too bold, I bring up my own flaws so I can be sure people don't think I think I'm something special.  Whether I am or not, when in a room with men used to working with men, it's best not to show them up ever.  This might be anti-feminist of me, I'm not sure, but I also think it's a smart career move, and I don't think many women make it into upper management by being as aggressive as their male counterparts.  

This past Christmas I was invited to a luncheon my company was hosting for a pharmaceutical company we work very closely with.  I had only been working here for 6 months at this point, and no other young engineers were invited so I was very excited about going.  Upon arrival, I drank a quick vodka club (SOCIAL LUBRICANT!) and made a stupid joke to a guy I had worked with before about him being shorter than me (I am 5'10" and was wearing 4" heels, so really most people there were).  Self deprecation mode kicking in, I turned the joke around on me and pointed out how enormous I am etc etc.  He chatted with me throughout the whole lunch and told me I am very "endearing".  Did my joke, akin to the jokes I hear my male colleagues making with each other all the time, endear me to him or was I endearing despite the snarky comment?  Did I get called a "bitch" later on behind my back, or did people appreciate my wit and ball-busting?  I want people to like me but I also want them to know I am competent, and I think, in the burgeoning male-dominated industries, this is the new "can women have it all?" struggle.  


2 comments:

  1. I often struggle with the balance between humility/self deprecation and confidence/snobbery too. I've slowly started to move away from totally rejecting compliments ("Really? I don't think so!") to at least half accepting them with a humble tone ("Thanks, I try and make an effort!") because I, like you, worried that I might subconsciously be nursing a low self esteem.

    Regarding not showing up men ever... I totally agree. Sorry feminists! I think in a professional setting women have to tread carefully because many men hate to feel humiliated/belittled. And... it can be totally unpredictable what makes them feel that way... even something you thought was a bland or innocent remark :P That's not to say I don't think women should be powerful or hide their intelligence... we just have to be aware of office politics :)

    Great post.

    Quinn
    www.Desgettier.com

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Thank you so much for your comment! It's so true, you never know what's going to make someone feel belittled and then turn on you. I'm learning to just keep my mouth shut in most cases

      Delete